Independent ERISA fiduciary since 19973(16) & 402(a) — we sign and file your Form 5500No products sold, no commissionsTalk to us: (361) 271-1211

Late deferral deposits are one of the most common operational failures a plan sponsor can discover, and one of the most misunderstood. When employee salary deferrals reach the plan trust later than the law allows, the employer has held plan assets, and that makes this a fiduciary matter rather than a clerical one. This article walks sponsors through how to catch the problem, cure it, calculate lost earnings and answer the Form 5500 late-remittance question.

Why a Late Deposit Is Fiduciary, Not Clerical

Employee deferrals become plan assets as soon as they can reasonably be separated from the employer’s general assets. From that point, the employer is handling money that belongs to participants. Holding it past the required window is treated as a use of plan assets by the employer, which implicates the prohibited transaction rules. For background on the rules, see our guide to 401(k) contribution remittance and timely deposit rules and our overview of prohibited transactions for 401(k) sponsors.

The standard sponsors should hold in mind is the earliest date the deferrals can reasonably be segregated from general assets. Small plans may have a safe harbor window available, but the specifics depend on your plan size and document, so confirm with your document provider rather than relying on a rule of thumb.

How Late Deposits Happen

Step One: Catch It

1. Compare payroll dates to deposit dates

The only reliable way to find a late deposit is to line up each payroll date against the date the money posted at the recordkeeper or trust. Do this for every pay cycle, not a sample.

2. Look for the quiet cases

Off-cycle checks, terminated employee final pay and bonuses are where late deposits hide. Pull them separately.

3. Use the recordkeeper’s own data

Ask for the posting dates as the trust recorded them. Your payroll register shows when you withheld, and the recordkeeper shows when the plan received. The gap is the issue.

4. Ask who else saw the numbers

Auditors, payroll vendors and your participant data reconciliation process often surface a pattern before management does.

Step Two: Cure It

1. Deposit the late amounts immediately

Stop the clock. If deferrals are still sitting in the operating account, send them to the plan now. Delay compounds the lost earnings and the exposure.

2. Calculate lost earnings

Participants must be made whole for what the money would have earned had it been deposited on time. The usual approach measures earnings from the date the deferral should have been deposited to the date it was actually deposited, using the participant’s actual investment returns or the plan’s available method. Confirm the method with your recordkeeper or administrator, since plan design and investment menu affect the calculation.

3. Pay lost earnings from the employer’s pocket

The employer funds the lost earnings, not participants and not plan assets. They are deposited to the affected participants’ accounts, not paid to them in cash.

4. Document every number

Keep the payroll register, the posting dates, the calculation and the proof of the corrective deposit. This is the file an auditor or the DOL will ask for.

Step Three: Correct the Pattern, Not Just the Pay Period

1. Find the root cause

A one-time delay is different from a systemic gap. Trace which payrolls, which entities and which employee types were affected.

2. Fix the process

Move to automatic remittance tied to the payroll run, assign a named backup, and add a standing reconciliation. The point is to remove the dependence on a single person remembering.

3. Fold it into your broader correction approach

Late deposits sit alongside other operational failures. Our guide to 401(k) administrative error correction and the dedicated page on late deferral deposits correction cover the mechanics in more depth.

The Form 5500 Late-Remittance Question

1. Where the question appears

The annual return asks whether participant contributions were deposited late. If any were, the sponsor must answer accordingly, and the answer cannot be skipped because the amounts were small or have since been corrected.

2. Why it matters for the signer

The person signing is attesting to accuracy. Before anyone signs, understand who signs the Form 5500 and use the practice of reviewing the Form 5500 before signing. Our Form 5500 filing page explains how this fits the annual process.

3. Reporting and correction are linked

Disclosing a late deposit on the return and correcting it are separate steps. Reporting does not cure the failure, and correcting does not remove the disclosure obligation for the plan year in question. Ask your advisor how the correction timing interacts with your plan year.

4. Consider the formal program

Some sponsors choose to use a formal correction program for added comfort and, in appropriate cases, relief from certain excise tax consequences. That decision is covered in our separate piece on the Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program, so this article does not repeat it. Whether it fits your facts is a question for your fiduciary advisor.

An Eight-Step Self-Check

  1. Pull every payroll date and every plan deposit date for the period in question.
  2. Identify every deposit that fell outside the reasonable-segregation window.
  3. Include off-cycle, bonus and final pay checks.
  4. Deposit any unremitted deferrals now.
  5. Calculate lost earnings by participant using the agreed method.
  6. Fund the lost earnings from employer assets into participant accounts.
  7. Answer the Form 5500 question accurately and confirm what the signer reviewed.
  8. Document the root cause, the fix and who now owns remittance.

Where Sponsors Get Hurt

What You Can Delegate and What You Cannot

You can delegate the monitoring, the reconciliation and the lost earnings calculation to a qualified administrator, and you can delegate the paperwork on the return. Under a 3(16) plan administration arrangement, much of the recurring remittance oversight and filing support is handled for you. What you cannot hand off is the employer’s own data and decisions: when deferrals were actually withheld, whether your funding was available and whether the money was used for other purposes. Only the sponsor knows those facts, and only the sponsor can fund the correction. For the broader picture, see 401(k) fiduciary liability and our summary of what happens if your 401(k) is out of compliance.

Put a Named Fiduciary Behind the Fix

Late deposits recur when nobody owns the decision. Admin316 accepts formal appointment as your plan’s ERISA 402(a) named fiduciary, which most providers decline, so responsibility for these calls rests with a named party rather than floating between payroll, HR and the recordkeeper. If you found a late deposit or suspect one, book a conversation with Admin316 and we will walk through the facts with you.

Not sure if you’re carrying fiduciary risk you don’t need to?Call (361) 271-1211Book a 15-min 3(16) fit check

Step 1 of 2 — Your name and phone

Tell us who to prepare the review for, then we’ll grab a few plan details.

For Plan Sponsors, CEOs, Business Owners & HR Professionals. Company retirement plans only.
Admin316 Retirement Administration · 4639 Corona Dr #26, Corpus Christi, TX 78411 · (361) 271-1211 · Mon–Fri 8:00 a.m.–5:00 p.m. Central · Independent ERISA fiduciary since 1997